Menu Close

Browns vs. Steelers: Expert Pick and Prediction – September 18, 2023

Browns vs. Steelers: Expert Pick and Prediction – September 18, 2023

BROWNS VS. STEELERS: EXPERT PICK AND PREDICTION – September 18, 2023 — A week ago, the Cleveland Browns started their season with the opponent they needed: Cincinnati at home. For whatever reason, the Browns have dominated the Bengals in Cleveland, winning six straight over their Ohio rivals at home.

It’s been the exact opposite situation facing the Steelers in Pittsburgh.

Since the Steelers opened Heinz Field in 2000, the Browns are 1-21 in Pittsburgh in the regular season. Outside of their playoff win in 2021, they’ve lost 19 straight to the Steelers in Pennsylvania. That includes last season, when Cleveland faded in the second half and ended up with a 28-14 loss to Pittsburgh.

That might be helpful for Kenny Pickett to point to after the quarterback had a nightmare start to his season. Pickett looked awful against San Francisco last week, and while the 49ers will do that to a lot of teams, the lack of progression from last season was alarming. Pickett went 7-2 as a rookie, but that was because of the Steelers’ defense more than him. That included last year’s win over the Browns, as Pickett didn’t play particularly well in the season finale either.

Related: Toby Wreathway’s NFL Week 2 Betting Preview

The Odds

Matchup Open Spread Points Moneyline
Cleveland Browns

(1-0 SU, 1-0-0 ATS)

O42 -2 O38.5 -135
Pittsburgh Steelers

(0-1 SU, 0-1-0 ATS)

-1 +2 U38.5 +115


When: Monday, September 18th at 8:20 p.m. EDT

Where: Acrisure Stadium, Pittsburgh


Public Bets: 57% on Cleveland

Public Money: 57% on Pittsburgh

Odds courtesy of DraftKings, as of September 17th, 2023

Browns vs. Steelers In-Season Trends

For Cleveland, the magic number is 21. Over the past five seasons, when the Browns get to 21 against the Steelers, they’re 4-0-1. When they don’t, they’re 0-6. Part of that has been the Steelers’ defense, which has needed to make play after play in this series to keep the wins coming.

Related: NFL Week Two Fantasy Sleepers 

Steelers’ coach Mike Tomlin doesn’t just know how to beat the Browns in Pittsburgh; he also knows how to cover the number. The Steelers’ coach has never lost to Cleveland in the regular season, boasting a 16-0 SU mark. He’s 10-5-1 ATS, and four of the Steelers’ past five wins in the rivalry have come by double digits.

The Difference-Makers

Browns vs. Steelers
Kenny Pickett owns a 1-1 career record against the Cleveland Browns. (Photo by Nick Cammett/Getty)

Pickett didn’t look good at all against the 49ers’ blitz last week, which means he’ll surely see it again this week. Jim Schwartz has always been a fan of the blitz, and he successfully shut Joe Burrow down last week by sending pressure early and often. With Pickett struggling badly against the blitz, there’s no reason for the Browns to change what worked for them.

Either Deshaun Watson has to be better than he was last season against the Steelers, or the Browns will need to lean on Nick Chubb. Cleveland should probably consider doing the latter anyway, given that Chubb nearly managed six yards a carry last year in Pittsburgh.

He got 18 carries against Cincinnati last week and responded with 106 rushing yards. If the Browns can keep feeding him, they’ll likely control the game.


Showers will happen early in the day in Pittsburgh, but by the time the teams kick off, the rain should be out of the way. Temperatures will sit in the 50s by kickoff, which means football weather.

The Pick

The Browns’ defense looked very good last week, and the Steelers’ passing attack didn’t look good at all. I don’t want to overreact to Week 1, but Pickett has shown more bad than good in his brief NFL career and did not handle a good blitz last week.

With Myles Garrett coming for him and Pickett already showing he couldn’t handle Cleveland’s defense in his first opportunity, I don’t see any reason to change things up here.

Dan’s Picks

Browns -2.5

Under 38.5

FUN My Pillow


  • Dan Angell, Contributor

    Dan is originally from Virginia and has covered basketball games across the country over the past 18 years. He now resides in Indianapolis and loves a good defensive showcase. His Twitter @danangell11.

    View all posts

1 Comment

  1. Pingback:Chicago Bears: Three Biggest Takeaways from 27-17 Loss to Bucs

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *